TV-series
Mahou Shoujotai - 97/100
Noein - 96/100
Bokura no - 95/100
Kaiba - 95/100
Revolutionary Girl Utena - 95/100
Simoun - 95/100
The Third - 95/100
Figure 17 - Tsubasa and Hikaru - 94/100
Haibane Renmei - 94/100
Kaze no Shoujo Emily - 94/100
Les Miserables - Shoujo Cosette - 94/100
Mushishi - 94/100
Shion no Ou - 94/100
Toward the Terra - 94/100

Asatte no Houkou - 93/100
Baccano! - 93/100
Dennou Coil - A Circle of Children - 93/100
Hi no Tori - 93/100
Himitsu ~The Revelation~ - 92,5/100
Ghost Hound - 92/100
Jigoku Shoujo - 92/100
Mermaid’s Forest - 92/100
Otogi Juushi Akazukin - 92/100
Eureka 7 - 91/100
Higurashi no Naku Koro ni - 91/100
Le Chevalier d’Eon - 91/100
Now and Then, Here and There - 91/100
Seirei no Moribito - 91/100
Air - 90/100
Amatsuki - 90/100
Flag - 90/100
Gunslinger Girl - Il Teatrino - 90/100
Nodame Cantabile - 90/100
Saiunkoku Monogatari - 90/100
Sayonara Zetsubou-Sensei - 90/100
The Law of Ueki - 90/100
xxxHolic - 90/100
xxxHolic: Kei - 90/100

Bakumatsu Kikansetsu Irohanihoheto - 89/100
Crystal Blaze - 89/100
El Cazador de la Bruja - 89/100
Jubei-Chan Siberian Yagyuu - 89/100
Master of Epic - 89/100
Mokke - 89/100
Pani Poni Dash - 89/100
Rumiko Takahashi’s Rumic Theater - 89/100
Demashitaa! Power Puff Girls Z - 88/100
Hakaba Kitarou - 88/100
Hitohira - 88/100
Jigoku Shoujo Futakomori - 88/100
Narutaru - 88/100
Ooedo Rocket - 88/100
Tenpou Ibun Ayakashi Ayashi - 88/100
Bokura ga Ita - 87,5/100
Mobile Police Patlabor - 87,5/100
Natsume Yuujin-Chou - 87,5/100
RD Sennou Chousashitsu - 875/100
Rozen Maiden - 87,5/100
Yomigaeru Sora - Rescue Wings - 87,5/100
Ayakashi ~ Japanese Classic Horror - 87/100
Boogiepop Phantom - 87/100
Darker than Black - 87/100
Ergo Proxy - 87/100
Gilgamesh - 87/100
Kino no Tabi - 87/100
Soultaker - 87/100

Druaga no Tou ~The Aegis of Uruk~ - 86/100
ef - a Tale of Memories - 86/100
Human Crossing - 86/100
Kurenai - 86/100
Mononoke - 86/100
Night Head Genesis - 86/100
Soukou no Strain - 86/100
Shigofumi ~ Stories of the Last Letter - 86/100
True Tears - 86/100
Yamato Nadeshiko Shichi Henge - 86/100

Antique Bakery - 85/100
Armored Trooper Votoms - Pailsen Files - 85/100
Ayatsuri Sakon - 85/100
Beck - Mongolian Chop Squad - 85/100
Blassreiter - 85/100
Clannad - 85/100
Hataraki Man - 85/100
Kamichu - 85/100
Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha A’s - 85/100
Mahou Tsukai ni Taisetsu na Koto ~Natsu no Sora~ - 85/100
Mobile Suit Gundam - 85/100
Moyashimon - 85/100
Sasami Mahou Shoujo Club - 85/100
Serial Experiments Lain - 85/100
Spice and Wolf - 85/100
Ultraviolet: Code 044 - 85/100
Wild Arms - 85/100
Code-E - 84/100
Death Note - 84/100
Kekkaishi - 84/100
Muteki Kanban Musume - 84/100
NHK ni Youkoso - 84/100
Sentimental Journey - 84/100
Shigurui - 84/100
Alexander Senki - Reign the Conqueror - 83/100
Blue Drop - 83/100
Full Moon wa Sagashite - 83/100
Gundam 00 - 83/100
Kero Kero Chime - 83/100
Overman King Gainer - 83/100
Birdy the Mighty Decode - 82,5/100
Chi’s Sweet Home - 82,5/100
Hunter x Hunter - 82,5/100
Junjo Romantica - 82,5/100
Legendary Gambler Tetsuya - 82,5/100
Nijuu Mensou no Musume - 82,5/100
Rocket Girls - 82,5/100
Seto no Hanayome - 82,5/100
sola - 82,5/100
Solty Rei - 82,5/100

Blood+ - 82/100
Claymore - 82/100
D.N.Angel - 82/100
Sky Girls - 82/100
Suteki Tantei Labyrinth - 82/100
Wellber no Monogatari ~ Sisters of Wellber - 82/100
Gakuen Utopia Manabi Straight - 81/100
Good Witch of the West - Astraea Testament - 81/100
Kemonozume - 81/100
Kimikiss - Pure Rouge - 81/100
Mahou Tsukai Tai - 81/100
Makai Senki Disgaea - 81/100
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya - 81/100
Zoku Sayonara Zetsubou-Sensei - 81/100
Zombie Loan - 81/100
Avenger - 80/100
Black Heaven - 80/100
Macross Frontier - 80/100
Sci-Fi Harry - 80/100
Tetsuko no Tabi - 79/100
Trinity Blood - 79/100
Yami to Boushi to Hon no Tabibito - 79/100
Black Lagoon - 78/100
Kazemakage Tsukikage Ran - 78/100
Kenko Zenrakei Suieibu Umisho - 78/100
Seraphim Call - 78/100
Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann - 78/100
Betterman - 77,5/100
King of Bandit Jing - 77,5/100
Mission-E - 77,5/100
Persona - Trinity Soul - 77,5/100
Strike Witches - 77,5/100
Wind - A Breath of Heart - 77,5/100
Asagiri no Miko - 77/100
Ginga Densetsu Weed - 77/100
Reideen - 77/100

100 Stories - 76/100
Kodomo no Jikan - 76/100
NieA Under 7 - 76/100
Orphen - 76/100
Yoshinaga-chi no Gargoyle - 76/100
Glass no Kantai - 75/100
Sekirei - 75/100
.Hack//Roots - 74/100
Ghost Hunt - 74/100
Hanoka - 74/100
Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS - 74/100
Toshokan Sensou - 74/100
Fruits Basket - 73/100
Heroic Age - 73/100
Jyuu Oh Sei - 73/100
Kishin Taisen Gigantic Formula - 73/100
Magikano - 73/100
Ouran High School Host Club - 73/100
Potemayo - 73/100
Tokyo Tribe 2 - 73/100
Bakuretsu Hunters - 72,5/100
Battle Programmer Shirase - 72,5/100
Code Geass - Lelouch of the Rebellion - 72,5/100
Toshokan Sensou - 72,5/100
Earth Girl Arjuna - 72/100

Bamboo Blade - 71/100
Nanatsuiro Drops - 71/100
Hatenkou Yuugi - 70/100
Slayers Revolution - 70/100
Space Battleship Yamato - 70/100
Utawarerumono - 70/100
Vampire Knight - 70/100
Yume de Aetara - 70/100
Shadow Skill - 68/100
Kannadzuki no Miko - 67/100
Soul Link - 65/100
Tsukuyomi Moon Phase - 65/100

Binbou Shimai Monogatari - 63/100
Mai Otome - 63/100
Shuffle! - 63/100
Wolf’s Rain - 62/100
Dragonaut - The Resonance - 62/100
Lucky Star - 60/100
Kamisama Kazoku - 59/100
Paradise Kiss - 57/100
Romeo x Juliet - 56/100

Shakugan no Shana - 51/100
School Days - 49/100
Afro Samurai - 47/100
Glass Mask - 45/100

Chocolate Underground - 37,5/100
Shining Tears X Wind - 34/100

For some quick indication as to what the numbers mean:
100-94: A masterpiece, the best of the best
93-90: Outstanding series, with perhaps one or two small flaws here and there
89-87: Excellent series, definitely worth a watch
86-83: Great series, really enjoyable to watch.
82-77: Good, but could have been better
76-72: Has some great points, but significant flaws are holding this series back
71-65: An average series with one or two great parts
64-56: Mediocre series, not really worth your time
55-40: Bad series, stay away from these
<39: Painful, garbage, crap, etc
No, don’t ask me why some of these numbers look really random. This is just the way my rating-system evolved.

Movies and OVAs
Tales of Phantasia - 95/100
The Dog of Flanders - 93/100
Tokyo Godfathers - 92/100
Eternal Family - 91/100
Millennium Actress - 91/100
Metropolis - 90/100
Spirited Away - 90/100
Rurouni Kenshin - Tsuiokuhen - 90/100

Arete Hime - 89/100
Comedy - 89/100
Jin Roh - The Wolf Brigade - 89/100
My Neighbour Totoro - 89/100
Tekkon Kinkreet - 89/100
Kiki’s Delivery Service - 88/100
Oseam - 88/100
Porco Rosso - 88/100
The Wings of Honneamise - 88/100
Adolescence of Utena - 87/100
Area 88 - 87/100
Mahou Tsukai Tai OVA - 87/100
Perfect Blue - 87/100
They Were 11 - 87/100
Toki wa Kakeru Shoujo - 87/100
Tsubasa Chronicle: Torikago no Kuni no Himegimi - 87/100
Alien Nine - 86/100
Arusu the Adventure - 86/100
The Cat Returns - 86/100
Hitsuji no Uta - 86/100
Hyper Future Vision: Gunnm - 86/100
FREEDOM - 85/100
Karura Mau - 85/100
Kimagure Robot - 85/100
Kino no Tabi - The Beautiful World - Byouki no Kuni -For You - 85/100
Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou - 85/100

Blue Submarine No.6 - 84/100
Card Captor Sakura - The Sealed Card - 84/100
Patlabor II - 84/100
Princess Mononoke - 84/100
Robot Carnival - 84/100
Space Fantasia 2001 Nights - 84/100
Twilight Q - 84/100
Whisper of the Heart - 84/100
xxxHolic Movie - 84/100
The Cockpit - 83/100
Laputa: Castle in the Sky - 83/100
Sentou Yousei Yukikaze - 83/100
Umi ga Kikoeru - 83/100
Genius Party - 07 - Baby Blue - 82,5/100
Kara no Kyoukai - The Garden of Sinners - Remaining Sense of Pain - 82,5/100
Kara no Kyoukai - The Garden of Sinners - 01 - 82/100
Kawaguchi Kaiji’s 9 Love Stories - 82/100
Like the Clouds, Like the Wind - 82/100
Neon Genesis Evangelion: The End of Evangelion - 82/100
Patlabor - 82/100
Pet Shop of Horrors - 82/100
Piano no Mori - 82/100
Black Jack - The Two Doctors of Darkness - 81/100
A Chinese Ghost Story - 81/100
Gauche the Cellist - 81/100
Karas - 81/100
Miyori no Mori - 81/100
Bus Gamer - 80/100
Genius Party - 02 - Shanghai Dragon - 80/100
Genius Party - 06 - Happy Machine - 80/100
Giant Robo - 80/100
Franz Kafka’s A Country Doctor - 80/100
Sword of the Stranger - 80/100
Tooi Umi Kita Kara Coo - 80/100
A Tree of Palme - 80/100
Wings of Rean - 80/100

Gedo Senki - 78/100
Only Yesterday - 78/100
Batman - Gotham Knight - 77,5/100
Kara no Kyoukai - The Garden of Sinners - A Study in Murder (Part 1)
.Hack//GU Trilogy - 77/100
Here is Greenwood - 77/100
My Beautiful Girl Mari - 77/100
Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind - 77/100
Please Save my Earth - 77/100
Vampire Hunter D - Bloodlust - 77/100
Akira - 76/100
Murder Princess - 76/100
Pom Poko - 76/100
Wonderful Days - 76/100
Black Magic M66 - 75/100
Genius Party - 01 - Genius Party - 75/100
Genius Party - 04 - Doorbell - 75/100
Golden Boy - 75/100
Interlude - 75/100
Kino no Tabi - Life Goes On - 75/100
Night on the Galactic Railroad - 75/100
Tales of a Streetcorner - 75/100
Tenchi Muyo! - Ryo-Ouki - 75/100

Escaflowne - A Girl in Gaea - 74/100
Ghost in the Shell - 74/100
Kai Doh Maru - 74/100
Paprika - 74/100
The Animatrix - 74/100
My Neighbours the Yamadas - 73/100
Spring and Chaos - 73/100
Highlander - Search for Vengeance - 72/100
Mind Game - 72/100
The Place Promised In Our Early Days - 72/100
3x3 Eyes - 71/100
Dead Leaves - 71/100
Aachi wa Ssipak - 70/100
Catblue Dynamite - 70/100
Nasu - Summer in Andalusia - 70/100
Takane no Jitensha - 70/100

Black Jack Special - 69/100
Neon Genesis Evangelion: Death and Rebirth - 69/100
Pale Cocoon - 69/100
Howl’s Moving Castle - 67/100
Fantastic Adventures of Unico - 66/100
Haru no Ashioto The Movie: Ourin Dakkan - 66/100
Nitaboh - 65/100

Mai Otome Zwei - 63/100
Spriggan - 61/100
Quiz Magic Academy OVA - 60/100

Rebuild of Evangelion 1.0: You Are (Not) Alone
The Diary of Tortov Roddle - 58/100

Vampire Hunter D - 51/100

Gin-Iro no Kami no Agito - 45/100

The Boy Who Saw The Wind - 44/100